Review by Katie Bickley
Are you going to Scarborough Fair?
Parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme
Remember me to one who lives there
She must be a true love of mine
For most listeners, the ballad Scarborough Fair strikes someone as not much more than a melancholy love song. It’s just a poor guy who’s in love with a woman who doesn’t love him back. Right?
After reading this book, you will never think that again.
Lucy Scarborough is an average teenager—she has awesome friends, a cute date for her prom, and loving foster parents. The only thing that really gives her pains is her birth mother, Miranda, who’s insane in the clinical sense of the word. She dips in and out of her daughter’s otherwise normal life.
Then comes the night of Lucy’s disastrous prom. Once it’s over, Lucy discovers that she’s pregnant, and subsequently learns of a curse placed on all the “Scarborough girls”, as they’re called: upon giving birth, each of Lucy’s female ancestors have gone crazy. She has nine months to break the curse. With the help and love of a long-time friend, Zach, she just might be able to do it.
This book pulled me in with nearly flawless, intriguing writing and kept me going through a plot full of surprise turns and fairytale magic. Lucy and Zach’s love is one of the most heartfelt, caring relationships I’ve read in a long time. In fact, all of the relationships are handled with a tender touch, from Lucy’s interaction with Miranda to Soledad and Leo’s concern for their daughter. I am deeply impressed this book—Nancy Werlin’s sinister twist on this ballad was Impossible to put down.